Discipline and Dismissal

Breaking News

This is one major mistake made by employers which could prove costly

Ivan Israelstam


Employers make two common mistakes on receiving misconduct allegations against employees. The first is that they ignore the reports because acting on them is "too much trouble" or because they are scared of infringing on the myriad legal labour rights that employees enjoy. This constitutes dereliction of duty or ignorance of the legal process on the part of the management.

Alternatively, the managers may hastily implement discipline without first investigating the validity of the reports. This may occur due to feelings of anger or to ignorance of the labour law pertaining to disciplinary processes. Investigation of misconduct allegations is a crucial step in legally acceptable disciplinary action and cannot be bypassed.

In the case of TGWU obo Joseph and others v Grey Security Services (Western Cape) (Pty) Ltd (2004, 6 BALR 698) a number of security guards were dismissed after the employer's client requested the employer to remove the guards from the premises for having been involved in dishonest practices.

The employees refused to be transferred away from the client's site and they were, therefore, dismissed. The CCMA found the dismissals to be substantively unfair. This was because the employer had not investigated the client's allegations of dishonesty against the guards.

The employer was ordered to reinstate all the employees with full back pay and to pay their costs. Such a costly reinstatement might not have occurred had the employer investigated the conduct alleged by the client.

Who should investigate?

The investigator should ideally be - but does not have to be - the same person who is going to present the case for the employer at the disciplinary hearing. This person is normally known as the "complainant" or "initiator". 

What is the purpose of the investigation?

Investigation is an exercise designed to test allegations or suspicions, to find out what really happened and to establish whether there are grounds for disciplinary action. If the investigation shows that there probably was serious wrongdoing, the evidence gathered will also be used to prepare and present the case against the employee at a disciplinary hearing.

How long should the investigation last?

There is no specified time period for completion of an investigation. However, the investigation must commence without delay and must only be halted when the investigator is fully satisfied that every stone has been turned over. The length of the investigation depends on the nature of the case, the amount of evidence, and the availability of witnesses and other evidence.

Typically, a good investigator will find that the more evidence he/she uncovers, the more leads there are. It is only when this process of following all lines of inquiry has been exhausted that the investigation can be halted.

Must the employee know of the hearing?

It is not a standard legal requirement that employees be informed an investigation is on the go. This is more particularly so if an issue, and not a person, is being investigated; or informing the suspect could genuinely enable him/ her to interfere with and jeopardise the investigation.

Nevertheless, employers should be very careful about interfering with the employee's right to privacy. This is especially so where the investigation probes the employee's private life instead of workplace matters. Suspension during investigations The employer should only consider suspension if there is a real danger in keeping the employee on the premises. Any such suspension must be with pay, in writing and must make clear that it is only a temporary measure.

What makes a good investigator?

Concluding an investigation that optimises the chances of a successful disciplinary hearing requires a great deal of skill.

Investigators need to know how to:

  • Identify relevant witnesses, documents and other evidence;

  • Engage with witnesses so as to elicit the true and complete facts;

  • Recognise a new lead when it arises;

  • Keep within the laws limiting the rights of an investigator;

  • Put all the facts gathered into a clear and comprehensive report; and

  • Question suspects without letting on that they are suspects.


As these skills are difficult to develop, investigators and complainants should be trained by experts in labour law and in the investigation of misconduct.

  • Ivan Israelstam is chief executive of Labour Law Management Consulting. He can be contacted on 011- 888-7944 or 082-852-2973 or at

  • Our appreciation to Ivan and The Star newspaper for permission to publish this article

Courses and Workshops

Our Clients


Basic Labour Relations

28 March 2018

Emperors Palace: Convention Centre

POPI: Protection of Personal Information Act

29 March 2018 (Fully Booked)

Emperors Palace: Convention Centre

13 April 2018

Emperors Palace: Convention Centre

11 May 2018

Protea Hotel By Marriott Tyger Valley: Cape Town

The OHS Act and the Responsibilities of Management

04 April 2018

Southern Sun Hotel: OR Tambo International Airport

06 April 2018: Southern Sun

Elangeni & Maharani, Maharani Towers: Durban

Occupational injuries and diseases in the workplace

05 April 2018: Southern Sun

Elangeni & Maharani, Maharani Towers: Durban

12 April 2018

Southern Sun Hotel : OR Tambo International Airport

Employment Equity Committee Training

06 April 2018 (Fully Booked)

Emperors Palace: Convention Centre

18 April 2018

Southern Sun: Elangeni & Maharani, Elangeni Towers: Durban

11 May 2018

Emperors Palace: Convention Centre

18 May 2018

Protea Hotel By Marriott Tyger Valley: Cape Town

Skills Development Legislation and Review

11 April 2018

Southern Sun Hotel: OR Tambo International Airport

13 April 2018

Protea Hotel By Marriott Tyger Valley: Cape Town

19 April 2018

Southern Sun: Elangeni & Maharani, Maharani Towers: Durban

Managing Day to Day Issues/ Problem Employees Full day workshop

19 April 2018

Emperors Palace: Convention Centre

10 May 2018

Protea Hotel By Marriott Tyger Valley: Cape Town